Move to Main content area
:::

Review Procedures

2011-12-01
SML
  1. The reviewers who referee manuscripts submitted to the Journal are scholars and experts in the relevant fields of research.
  2. Reviewers are recommended by the Editor-in-Chief according to the nature of manuscript and field of research and after the Editorial Board members are consulted.
  3. After reviewing the manuscript, the two reviewers will check the publication suggestions and provide overall comments and suggestions for revision on the review form. Suggestions for publication are as follows:
    Review Method for Journal of Education Studies
    Method Second Reviewer's Comments
    Recommended for publication Revision required for publication Revision required for review Rejected
    First Reviewer's Comments Recommended for publication Publish Manuscript returned for revision before publication Revision required for review Third reviewer
    Revision required for publication Manuscript returned for revision before publication Manuscript returned for revision before publication Revision required for review Third reviewer
    Revision required for review Revision required for review Revision required for review Revision required for review Rejected
    Rejected Third reviewer Third reviewer Rejected Rejected
    1. If the third reviewer recommends the manuscript for publication or suggests revision before publication, the manuscript will be returned to the author for revision before the secondary review is conducted according to the procedures.
    2. If the third reviewer proposes revision for review, the Journal's Editor-in-Chief will make the final decision.